Active and Passive Euthanasia 2 Essay ..

Accepting that there is a distinction between active and passive euthanasia will result in decisions about life and death being made on irrelevant grounds. Rachels (1991: 104) offers the example of two Down Syndrome babies, one born with an obstructed intestine, and one born perfectly healthy in all other respects. In many cases, babies born with this condition are refused the simple operation that could cure it and so die. It does not seem right that an easily curable digestive ailment should determine whether the baby lives or dies. If Down Syndrome babies lives are judged to be not worth living, then both babies should die. If not, they should both be given medical treatment sufficient to ensure their survival. Accepting a distinction between active and passive euthanasia results in unacceptable inconsistencies in our treatment of such babies, and should therefore be abolished.

Passive And Active Euthanasia Essay Examples - …

Many people make a moral distinction between active and passive euthanasia.

Active and passive euthanasia essay

The Passive And Active Forms Name: National 5 Writing Folio Discursive essay Should the death penalty be brought discursive in the United Kingdom?

maintain distinction between passive and active euthanasia.

Heidegger supports euthanasia and assisted suicide Introduction The question of euthanasia raises serious moral issues, since it implies that active essays will be taken to terminate human life.

The moral distinction between active and passive euthanasia, or between

Active vs. Passive Euthanasia Essay - 1023 Words

Active euthanasia may sometimes be preferable to passive euthanasia. Being allowed to die can be an incredibly painful process. A lethal injection, however, is less painful. Assuming a terminally ill patient decides he or she does not want to continue to suffer, and a doctor agrees to assist the patient terminate his or her life, surely consistency demands that the least painful form of euthanasia, intended to reduce suffering, is used (Rachels, 1991: 104).

Voluntary Active Euthanasia - Sample Essays - New York essay

In reality, there does not seem to be any morally significant difference between passive and active euthanasia. Deciding to refrain from treating a patient is morally equivalent to administering a lethal injection since the doctor ceases treatment knowing that the patient will die. The motivations and end result are the same: the only difference between the two cases is the means used to achieve death. In the case of passive euthanasia the doctor has made an informed decision that non-treatment is the better course of action. Choosing not to act is itself an action, and we are equally responsible for this. Therefore, there is no justification for viewing these actions differently.

Essay question:Is there a difference between active and passive euthanasia

Passive Euthanasia - Euthanasia Essay Example

In his essay “Active and Passive Euthanasia” James Rachels argues that active euthanasia should be avoided only to satisfy the law, not because of any perceived moral difference between active and passive.

This distinction between active and passive euthanasia is thought to …

How does active and passive euthanasia differ in terms …

It is often argued that doctors are justified in allowing their patients to die by withdrawing or withholding treatment, but are not justified in killing them. This difference in attitudes toward active and passive euthanasia seems generally accepted by the medical profession. Opponents of active euthanasia rely on the intuitive difference that killing someone is morally worse than letting them die. It is argued that a doctor who kills a patient directly causes the death, but a doctor who withdraws or withholds treatment merely allows that death. In contrast to this view, however, many argue that there is not any real significant moral difference between the two actions. Choosing not to act is itself an action, and we are equally responsible for this. Indeed, as there is no significant moral difference, active euthanasia may sometimes be preferable.

GET EVEN A BETTER ESSAY WE WILL WRITE A CUSTOM ESSAY SAMPLE ON Critical Summary: Active and Passive Euthanasia..

Active Euthanasia - Sample Essays - New York essay

Analysing this argument logically, it seems difficult to see how permitting voluntary active euthanasia, for compassionate reasons, and respect for individual autonomy, could change attitudes to killings that do not demonstrate these qualities. As Beauchamp argues, if the principles we use to justify active euthanasia are just, then any further action inspired by these principles must also be just (1982: 251). If we examine what really happened in Nazi Germany, the facts do not seem to support this sensational claim. A totalitarian system and racial prejudice were more responsible for those tragic events than was any acceptance of euthanasia.